Messageboard

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER

These lips are made for syncing (115,036) by Bill from the UK
Well, well, well. Isn't it interesting how we're suddenly all having these conversations now?

For years, a collection of fans have been pointing out the very same things: the increasing reliance on lip-syncing, the lack of genuine live performances, the increasingly uncomfortable-looking stage appearances, the questionable creative decisions and the general feeling that something has been off for quite some time.

And what happened whenever anyone dared mention it? Accusations of being negative, ungrateful, bitter, not a real fan or simply hating on Mariah. Apparently, being a fan meant enthusiastically applauding absolutely everything and pretending not to have eyes or ears.

Fast forward to 2026 and suddenly everyone's concerned, everyone's noticing, everyone's asking questions and expressing the very same opinions that were dismissed for years.

Perhaps the most exhausting part isn't what's happening now, but the years spent being shot down for daring to acknowledge it.

The longer this mysterious illness remains shrouded in secrecy, the more room there is for speculation, the more uncomfortable the questions become, and the less forgiving the press and fans will inevitably be. Silence might buy time, but it rarely buys goodwill.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 07:28)
Article: Mariah sparks concern with overly "stiff" performance (115,035) by D from United States
I've only watched a few clips, but it doesn't look that bad. I feel like most people know what they're getting when they go to a Mariah concert. She does the best she can with what she's got, and I'd rather have this over nothing. This way, we can at least keep an eye on her. It probably sounds better when you're actually there, and nostalgia likely takes over. The concert clips I've watched aren't any worse than the Christmas specials she's put out. The official "Glitter Medley (Live from the Caution Tour)" track sounds a lot better than the low-quality clips on YouTube. Her voice has changed and it's not going to sound like it did in her prime.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 06:50)
Brazil concert (115,034) by Bobby A from United States
I meant to type her 2013 fall.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 04:14)
this is a reply to message 115,032
Article: Mariah sparks concern with overly "stiff" performance (115,033) by Lainsky from Philippines
After seeing the concert reels, I quietly thought, "The fans will not let this go unnoticed. It'll spark numerous and varied comments." And it did. I concur with some of those comments, though.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 04:08)
Brazil concert (115,032) by Bobby A from United States
It is sad to watch. It just dawned on me why MC has stopped doing U.S. shows. The U.S. media and social media would report about it and tear her to pieces. Their reporting would be too devasting for MC. I don't think she could take it this time. Reddit and X posters and have been so cruel recently to singers who can't sing live. They have not been nice this year to those artists. MC is definitely saving herself from reliving 2017.

Could her in 2014 fall have caused her now utterly awardness doing normal gross and fine motor functions? She was definitely good with her stage presence before 2014. It has to be the effects of her fall.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 02:33)
this is a reply to message 115,028
Brazil concert (115,031) by BFF from US
She had to use the 2009 recordings because she didn't have enough vocal rest to allow her to pre-record new 2026 vocals. She had to change ensembles as part of her Gucci endorsement deal, and ensemble changes are a part of her post-modern social commentary on the struggles of being a diva in a post-diva world. People just don't understand the performance art aspect of Mariah's shows.

I thought the ad-libbed "Yeahs" and "Heys" were really beautiful. She powered through stiff lip syndrome to delivered some really great notes for Brazilian lambs.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 02:20)
this is a reply to message 115,028
New Mariah Carey Christmas Barbie (115,030) by D from United States
I'm so excited about this. I'm middle-aged but a little girl inside. I hope it sells well so we get more in the future.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 23:25)
MC (115,029) by Dave from USA
At this point, i'm really feeling that she is suffering from something physically that she hasn't shared (not that she has to). Any psych meds shouldn't render her completely robotic like this. There is definitely something more involved with her health than what we are already aware of.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 23:01)
Brazil concert (115,028) by Terna from Nigeria
It's just sad, this is like watching Whitney Houston all over again but worse. Whitney was still human like and a fighter and you could tell was giving her very best to the best of her limitations. Mariah is borderline a whole robot now. Just stands there, does a terrible lipsynch job for the climaxes (like how are you still using vocals from 2009?), shrieks in a struggle high note or two as if to prove something and waddles off stage for another "ensemble" change. I'm really beginning to dislike this woman. Just ship her off to Iyanla Vanzant for rehabilitation. Ugh.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 20:47)
Mariah (115,027) by BFF from US
The vocalized speech during the glam moments was some of the best of her entire career. I could tell that those sections were completely live and that she was practicing with a spoken vocal coach to ensure that she was hitting the notes.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 18:39)
this is a reply to message 115,024
Brazil videos (115,026) by TJ from Norway
Haha. SLS. That syndrome made my day.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 18:18)
this is a reply to message 115,023
Tommy Mattola interview PBD Podcast (115,025) by Chicago Lamb from USA
Hello Webmaster, Please create hyperlink. I think it's a critical listen for any Mariah enthusiast.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 17:57)
this is a reply to message 115,019
Mariah (115,024) by nancy from Switzerland
I saw the Brazil [video]. I didn't expect anything from her at this point. She doesn't care if people know that she doesn't sing live anymore. As long people pay for the tickets, she continues to do the same freaking thing. As long she keeps on making money she will [never] stop. In this 2 hours there were so many breaks. One time for dress fixing, extensive make up retouches with Dior and Christopher, and the breaks where she had to change the ensembles. These breaks, where the dancers substitute MC, are getting longer and longer. The positive thing was, that she interacted with the audience. We know by now that she can't walk properly without the high heels. But she refuses to wear a bit lower heels. She is stubborn as a mule. There are so many other [Christmas] concerts who are worth paying for.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 16:31)
Brazil videos (115,023) by BFF from US
I was very impressed with the way she spoke to the audience. She vocalized "Let me hear you, Sao Paolo" very well. She sounded very rested on that part, and I think it's one of her best performances in a long time. I give her grace because I know she struggles with a rare disorder called stiff lip syndrome which makes it hard to lip sync. I really appreciate the meta-performance art aspect of her shows. She's using lip syncing as cultural and social commentary on the inherent artificiality of "live" shows. I'm planning to pursue a PhD in cultural studies and think it would be cool to write about Mariah's very intellectually stimulating performance art.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 14:27)
this is a reply to message 115,020
Brazil videos (115,022) by Jamie from UK
I'm going to watch her now after saying no but only because I got free tickets.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 12:38)
this is a reply to message 115,020
Try her shoes (115,021) by Lara from Middle East
Blame it on the meds. But also I don't think her lifestyle is helping. Mariah had top notch pen game, medications and age severely affected her creativity. Medications also with probably alcohol are causing her gait problem. Imagine yourself that despite all these limitations, you still love music and performing and need money to maintain that extravagant lifestyle. That's where Mariah is.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 12:32)
Brazil videos (115,020) by Lee from UK
Watching the videos coming out of Brazil have made me sad. The pre-records are scandalous and she is giving nothing on stage. It's such a shame. On the other hand, I have never been more pleased with my decision not to pay to watch Mariah "perform live" again. I said absolutely not to the Christmas shows when she announced she was coming to the UK but I dithered over the Firefly tour before ultimately remembering the Sandringham event last year. The Brazil videos show that she does not care to even put the effort in to make us believe she is singing live. The only way I would change my mind and go see her live is if she did an unplugged, acoustic set in a small venue. I would pay the extortionate ticket prices to attend something stripped back and 100% live.
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 09:20)
Tommy Mattola interview (115,019) by Chicago Lamb from USA
Listen here. Webmaster please create hyperlink. [Webmaster: I boycott X due to Musk's policies.]
(0:00) Intro
(1:53) Breaking Into Music
(8:57) Who Is Tommy Mottola?
(13:40) Hall & Oates
(18:35) Joe Pesci
(21:58) Meat Loaf & Other Artists
(25:26) Celine Dion & Finding Talent
(33:17) Springsteen & John Gotti
(37:02) Sharon Osbourne & Top Voices
(44:16) Mariah Carey (actually starts a little before w/Party meet A'la Brenda)
(59:20) All I Want for Christmas
(1:07:56) The Michael Jackson Feud
(1:20:11) 50 Cent, Alicia Keys & Music Power
(1:24:17) Roy Cohn & We Are the World
(1:31:04) Thalía & Life After Two Marriages
(Wednesday 18 November 2026; 04:27)
Article: 2027 Grammy nomination snubs and surprises (115,018) by TJ from Norway
Jessica Rabbit. The picture could be a commercial for that movie. Just change the colour of the dress.
(Tuesday 17 November 2026; 21:48)
Grammy's (115,017) by Zachariah from Croatia
Mariah is all grown up now, and the Grammy's are no longer the validation she needs or seeks. At this point, she can afford to laugh at them, shade them, and keep it moving. I'm fully supportive of this era and praying she gets even meaner. Let that pettiness flourish. She's no longer seeking their validation, she's reached the stage where she can afford to mock the institution.
(Tuesday 17 November 2026; 19:04)
Grammy snub? (115,016) by Lara from Middle East
Lol that snub made people realize she released an album.
(Tuesday 17 November 2026; 15:01)
Article: 2027 Grammy nomination snubs and surprises (115,015) by D from United States
Aw.
(Tuesday 17 November 2026; 10:45)
this is a reply to message 115,014
Article: 2027 Grammy nomination snubs and surprises (115,014) by Lighty from China
Miley said in an interview that Mariah presented her the Best Pop Solo Performance award at the 2024 Grammys and directly left after that. She didn't even bother to sit down.
(Tuesday 17 November 2026; 10:27)
this is a reply to message 115,013
Article: 2027 Grammy nomination snubs and surprises (115,013) by D from United States
Can Mariah still attend the Grammys even if she isn't nominated? I love seeing her dressed up at awards shows. Even if her albums aren't taking home awards anymore, she's still music royalty. I'm sure plenty of other artists would love to meet her or even exchange a few words. The Grammys would be the perfect spot for that. And the rest of us get to enjoy watching her look sparkly and magical on TV.

I saw someone post something that I loved: "Some albums win awards. Others help us survive." Mariah's albums have helped so many of us survive. That says more than any award ever could.

Some of the albums nominated this year are really good, too. I really like Olivia Dean and Olivia Rodrigo's albums, and I'm planning on listening to Rosalia's next.

I will say that I don't agree with Beyoncé having as many Grammys as she does. It makes me question whether the Grammys are as fair and objective as they should be. But that doesn't take away from my appreciation for the albums nominated this year.

(And just to be clear, I do enjoy Beyoncé. She's one of the biggest stars of our time. She's an incredible performer and singer, and she seems like a genuinely good person. I can appreciate her hard work, talent, and success while still questioning the way the Grammys decide who wins.)
(Tuesday 17 November 2026; 06:16)
These boots are made for walking (115,012) by jaker20 from US
I'm glad she got rid of the heels, already she looks happy, laid back, confident, and gorgeous. She can wear heels on stage if she wants but I just want to see her looking healthy.
(Tuesday 17 November 2026; 03:45)

MORE MESSAGES

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER



If you want to leave a message, there are a few rules you must follow:
1. This is a Mariah Carey messageboard, so the message must be related to Mariah Carey.
2. Only messages in English will be posted. And please try to write understandable English, with the proper use of dots and capitals.
3. Messages with all capitals will be ignored.
4. Messages that are insulting (to Mariah, other artists or members of this messageboard) will not be posted.
The webmaster has the right to refuse any message he doesn't like.
© MCArchives 1998-2026 (28 years!)
NEWS
MESSAGEBOARD