Messageboard

About Edward from USA:

What's wrong with Mariah (111,282) by Edward from USA Bobby A, if you break your hip at 30, what are you supposed to do, sit around until you’re 60 to get it fixed? Please. That’s why Mariah sometimes moves a little stiff, giving robot realness. It's not her fault though, back them hip replacement technology wasn't that advanced. (Thursday 18 September 2025; 02:02) this is a reply to message 111,281

What's wrong with Mariah (111,281) by Bobby A from United States I don't think MC had hip replacement surgery at 30 years old. That type of surgery is generally for people 60 and above. (Thursday 18 September 2025; 00:50)

What's wrong with Mariah (111,274) by Edward from USA She actually ended up having hip replacement surgery. If you remember her MTV Cribs episode, she fell off a treadmill while working out in high heels. Classic Mariah. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 20:32) this is a reply to message 111,269

What's wrong with Mariah (111,269) by BFF from United States This video claims she had hip replacement surgery back in 2000? That sounds pretty outlandish - having hip replacement at the age of 30/31. What possibly could have been happening at that time to cause such a surgery? Doesn't make any sense to me. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 16:28)

Vegas residency (111,273) by Edward from USA At this point, I can appreciate some good lipping. Mariah has managed to fool me a couple of times, and honestly, I don't mind. It lets me relax instead of sitting on the edge of my seat, so I can just enjoy how great she looks and take in the whole performance. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 20:29) this is a reply to message 111,268

Vegas residency (111,268) by Jamie from UK Haha I know, imagine she comes out with full on 1994 vocals and shuts everyone up. Somehow I think we're a bit late in the day for live vocals now, which is sad but it's where we're at I guess. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 15:50)

Billboard Hot 100 (111,266) by Edward from USA I was just scrolling through the Billboard Hot 100 like I used to, and I'm flabbergasted, who are all these people? I think I only recognized about seven artists on the whole list. Times have really changed. That's why Mariah being at the top every single year with "AIWFCIY" is something we should never take for granted. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 15:38)

Curse or cuss (111,265) by Edward from USA Stacey, it's really sad. Even when we try to keep kids away from "bad words", like we used to call them, social media just blasts them from every angle. That's why the foundation they get at home is so important. Sure, they'll hear those words, but they should also know better than to actually use them. I remember when I was a kid, about 12 years ago, if I heard an adult outside my family cuss, I was shocked, I had never once heard my parents do it. Even now, I don't really cuss, though I might drop a word or two with friends, but it's not part of how I normally talk. I know it sounds harsh by today's standards, but where I grew up, if you disrespected your elders or cussed, you'd get smacked right on the mouth. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 15:12) this is a reply to message 111,250

Mariah's priorities (111,250) by Stacey from USA I am glad we have warnings. As a mom to three kids (17, 14, 12), I don't want my children thinking those words are acceptable in their daily language. Swear words lack credibility with me. Just so unnecessary, IMHO. Sure my kids are exposed to them daily in school. I teach them to avoid using those words. My hope is that they will use them sparingly like me, lol. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 01:17)

Vegas residency (111,264) by Edward from USA Jamie, you've set yourself up for a "I really hope she sings live this time, just so we can finally shut you up". I got one of those from Zachariah, and it was awesome. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 14:50) this is a reply to message 111,258

Vegas residency (111,258) by Jamie from UK Because she’s been doing it for years and more so recently. But if she sings live then bonus but highly doubt it (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 11:43)

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,259) by Edward from USA Autocorrect is killing me. Instead of "I like other artists" I meant "Unlike other artists". (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 12:19) this is a reply to message 111,251

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,251) by Edward from USA Stacey, I like other artists, Celine had a custom-built $75M, 4000-seat created just for her at Caesars Palace called The Collosseum. For years Vegas had the reputation of being where artists with fading careers went to perform, but Celine completely changed that narrative. She made performing in Vegas relevant and prestigious. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 04:11)

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,251) by Edward from USA Stacey, I like other artists, Celine had a custom-built $75M, 4000-seat created just for her at Caesars Palace called The Collosseum. For years Vegas had the reputation of being where artists with fading careers went to perform, but Celine completely changed that narrative. She made performing in Vegas relevant and prestigious. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 04:11) this is a reply to message 111,243

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,243) by Stacey from USA I saw Celine in Vegas in 2003. The whole idea seemed so odd. A huge artist like Celine playing Vegas? The same town that loves Wayne Newton? And yet, here we are with many artists doing the same thing years later. Celine was ahead of her time in this respect. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 17:40)

GTFO Clean (111,240) by Edward from USA Eric, thank you. I can't believe I had never listened to the clean version before. I have to admit though, it sounds pretty awful. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 16:52)

Mariah's priorities (111,238) by Edward from USA I'm very curious now. How does "GTFO" sound without the f part? I didn't even know there was such version. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 15:25) this is a reply to message 111,237

Mariah's priorities (111,237) by Stacey from USA I am well. Thanks for asking. I agree the swear word is so unnecessary. The censors here in the US are different. They may release an edited album version much like they did with Caution. I couldn't exactly listen to GTFO in my car with my kids, lol. The song HFIA is so beautiful on its own. I am fangirling over these amazing lyrics that take me back to 90s Mariah where her songwriting was so deep for such a young artist. 9 days people. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 15:06)

10 days (111,236) by Edward from USA Same sentiment here. I think that letting go of unrealistic expectations makes the experience so much better. Charts are the last thing on my mind when it comes to "HFIA", I'm just excited for the new music. The last time I felt this kind of anticipation was before E=MC² dropped. Unlike Stacey, I haven't caved in to listening to snippets, but I love reading all your thoughts about it. The anticipation is seriously killing me. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 15:03) this is a reply to message 111,234

10 days (111,234) by Bill from the UK Just 10 days until we finally get to hear new music. I don't know why but I am more excited for this album that I was for Caution and Me I Am Mariah. Something just feels different with this project. I hope there's some great moments on there. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 14:42)

Correction (111,222) by Edward from USA I meant to say the following on the third paragraph of message (111,212): "What really gets me is when some fans infantilize a 56-year-old to avoid holding her accountable for her choices and actions. Yes, she deserves lots of compassion and people around her who actually care, real friends who'll be honest, not just hype her up or leech off her. Even fans who used to deny it can see now that something's not right." (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 01:27)

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,218) by Edward from USA The album, if structured with the songs you listed, would've done so much better. MIAM definitely had some great tracks, but it also felt a little cluttered. A few songs seemed like they were just thrown in for the sake of filling space. (Monday 15 September 2025; 21:45) this is a reply to message 111,192

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,192) by Bill from the UK Here's my version of MIAM that I playlisted, rather than the actual album: 1. Make It Look Good 2. Beautiful 3. You Don't Know What to Do 4. You're Mine (Eternal) 5. Cry. 6. Faded 7. Dedicated 8. Almost Home 9. Mesmerised* 10. Triumphant (Get 'Em) 11. The Art of Letting Go *I know it's not strictly from the era, but I think it fits. I trimmed all the filler and weak tracks out, especially One More Try and Heavenly, as they are so Frankensteined they don't even sound like her. (Monday 15 September 2025; 09:59)

Mariah in Brazil (111,217) by Edward from USA I get what you're saying, but Mariah doesn't exactly operate on a normal timeline. If anything, she's eternally twelve, remember? (Monday 15 September 2025; 21:42) this is a reply to message 111,206

Mariah in Brazil (111,206) by MusicfanJ from Germany To be honest is mostly the best thing to do. At a certain age you should be able to speak the truth. Plus it often takes away negative critics, but if not a lot of people will be harsh and criticise even more. Mariah should be more honest at least. It's not always easy but better for the soul. I hope she gets more open about what's wrong. (Monday 15 September 2025; 16:27)

Mariah in Brazil (111,216) by Edward from USA What if her situation isn't about something out of her control, but rather something she's actually choosing to engage in? If that's the case, she'd never tell. (Monday 15 September 2025; 21:40) this is a reply to message 111,197

Mariah in Brazil (111,197) by Jamie from UK Yeah I agree Bill. I think at this point she would actually get more sympathy from the general public if she was just honest with them. So what if she’s got something, no one cares and would actually warm to her for being open and honest. (Monday 15 September 2025; 10:55)

Bundle (111,215) by Edward from USA If I were Mariah, I would bundle concert tickets with a digital copy of "Here For It All". This album feels way more anticipated than "Caution", and I really hope it does well. I'm definitely rooting for her. (Monday 15 September 2025; 21:38)

Armbracelet (111,212) by Edward from USA Mariah didn't break her shoulder, it was dislocated, which is a whole different thing. The doctors popped it back in, and with time it healed. She also cracked a rib. I bring this up because some fans love to rewrite history. Sure, maybe she doesn't have the same range of motion now, or maybe she's just being careful, who wouldn't be? But I don't think that old injury has anything to do with where she's at mentally today. Back then, she actually sang beautifully with that jeweled arm brace, and once she healed, she was fine. Things really started going downhill during Contourella's reign of terror. With her fake "empower women" nonsense, she convinced Mariah it was okay to act out and even let herself be photographed in humiliating situations. She was also the mastermind behind Mariah blaming promoters and "outside forces" after the New Year's Eve mess in 2016. That whole period left scars. And while Mariah was clearly manipulated, she wasn't completely innocent in it either, which makes it even sadder. She hasn't been the same since. Contourella basically walled her off and inserted herself into every part of her life right when Mariah was at her most vulnerable. What really gets me is when infantilize a 56-year-old to avoid holding her accountable for her choices and actions. Yes, she deserves lots of compassion and people around her who actually care, real friends who'll be honest, not just hype her up or leech off her. Even fans who used to deny it can see now that something's not right. It reminds me of Whitney's last tour. You just know people in her camp were saying, "You sound amazing, go on tour," when she was clearly struggling. That kind of denial is dangerous, and it feels like Mariah's being pushed down that same path. (Monday 15 September 2025; 18:27)

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,181) by Edward from USA Definitely a missed opportunity. In my humble opinion, "Triumphant" was stronger than a lot of tracks on MIAM and deserved a spot on the album, yet it wasn't even included as a bonus track. When it first dropped, people complained that Mariah sounded like a guest on her own song, but then she came back with those incredible remixes that proved her voice was still very much there. I still jam to them today. I'm sure there are more gems from that era sitting in the vault, and when they finally see the light of day, we'll all be in for a surprise. (Sunday 14 September 2025; 21:01) this is a reply to message 111,177

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,177) by BFF from United States I swear there is a great album buried within the clutter of the "Me I Am Mariah" album. I bet "The Art of Letting Go" would have done well if everything with that album launch had gone according to plan and Mariah hadn't hurt herself filming the "#Beautiful" remix video. I definitely would have tossed the "One More Try" cover, "Heavenly/No Ways Tired", and those unnecessary "remixes" of "It's A Wrap" and "Betcha Gon' Know". What a missed opportunity that album was. (Sunday 14 September 2025; 13:36)

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,170) by Edward from USA That's how it's been for me ever since Mariah's horrendous "One More Try" cover on MIAM. Before that, we could always count on her to deliver in the studio, but things have changed. I'm still super excited for the new album dropping so, but I'm also cautious with my expectations. At the end of the day, I like what I like. And honestly, checking out fan reviews beforehand feels just as valid as people reading reviews before buying something or going to a show. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 22:37) this is a reply to message 111,160

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,160) by T from USA The idea that I would let people rain on my parade before even hearing the music and forming an opinion for myself after waiting seven years is mind boggling. Taking in others opinions is part of the fun, but only after I form my own first. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 14:47)

Here For It All streaming party countdown (111,161) by Edward from USA Mariah will snatch that record before year's end. She's only two weeks away from it. It's going to be epic. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 15:07) this is a reply to message 111,159

Here For It All streaming party countdown (111,159) by BFF from United States Mariah's statistics, success, and resume speak for themselves. JD said it himself in that interview on The Breakfast Club. Kudos to JD for sticking up for her when the interviewers tried to insinuate that Mariah would not have had the comeback in 2005 without him. I remember when people tried that mess with Mariah herself and tried to insinuate that she would not have been successful without Tommy. As Mariah said on "Caution": "That's a no-no. No-no." Who cares about who got the most consecutive number ones or sent their first five or seven singles to number one? Mariah's the undisputed champ for solo artists in the United States and has the most cumulative weeks at number one for any act. And she wrote/produced on all of her number ones except for "I'll Be There". And over the next few years, she will almost certainly snatch back the record for song with most weeks at number one from Lil' Nas X and Shaboozey . They can both send her some flowers. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 14:40)

Here For It All (111,153) by Edward from USA To be honest, reading through everyone's opinions helps me prepare for what to expect. For me, true listening day is September 27. And I'll listen to it in sequence, as it was intended by Miss Carey. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 02:08) this is a reply to message 111,135

Here For It All (111,135) by Bill from the UK Eddie how can you resist? I will be up at 00:00:01 on 26 September to listen to the album. It's been too long since we had new material. I can't wait to read everybody's thoughts on the album, the board will be abuzz I am sure. I'm highly anticipating "Jesus I Do", and the cover of "My Love". Question: do y'all listen to a new MC album in order, even playing tracks familiar (T-Dang and Sugar Sweet) or go straight to those tracks you want to hear first? (Friday 12 September 2025; 17:34)

Signed copies (111,151) by Edward from USA There's a video of Mariah signing HFIA CD inserts for sale. That's smart. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 01:48)

Rumor tracklist with a grain of salt (111,149) by Edward from USA Bobby A, are you sure? That person should be reprimanded. That's the track I was most excited about. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 01:09) this is a reply to message 111,147

Rumor tracklist with a grain of salt (111,147) by Bobby A from United States There is no Reprimand MCA Mix hidden bonus track. The X user made it up to be funny that he had the tracklist in his hand. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 00:29)

Why the dislike? (111,148) by Edward from USA Not really. They say that beauty is in the ears of the beholder. (Saturday 13 September 2025; 01:02) this is a reply to message 111,142

Why the dislike? (111,142) by Tevin from USA Is it bad that I prefer "Why you made" remix over Crapfinity? Lol, (Friday 12 September 2025; 18:47)

Here For It All streaming party countdown (111,145) by Edward from USA I stand corrected, Whitney didn't send her first seven singles to #1. What she did do was send seven consecutive singles to #1, which is different, and that's a record in itself. As for "why are we talking about Whitney when it has nothing to do with Mariah's streaming party and the new album?" Simple because we can, since this board isn't an echo chamber where we can only talk about one thing. Whatever you and I post here is open to debate or opinion, that's just the way the cookie crumbles. (Friday 12 September 2025; 20:46) this is a reply to message 111,130

Here For It All streaming party countdown (111,130) by 4real4real from UK Whitney's first singles were Hold Me with Teddy Pendergrass which reached no 46, followed by You Give Good Live which reached no 3. She did not send her first five singles to number one. This record by Mariah is a well known and well documented fact and why are we talking about Whitney when it has nothing to do with Mariah's streaming party and the new album? (Friday 12 September 2025; 16:31)

MORE MESSAGES