Messageboard

About Edward from USA:

Here For It All (111,132) by Edward from USA Well, we're just weeks away from finally getting "Here For It All". I'm pretty sure the album will be online a few days early, since Amazon and other retailers usually ship so fans can have it by the release day. Seven freaking years... I really hope it's been worth the wait. Even if becomes available before September 26, I won't be listening until I have fully read all the comments here from day one. (Friday 12 September 2025; 16:52)

Why the dislike? (111,131) by Edward from USA I agree. I think "Don't Forget About Us" hit #1 mainly by riding the wave of "We Belong Together". If there's ever been a clone of "WBT", it's definitely "DFAU". Even though I prefer "DFAU" over "TGIFY", the production is definitely stronger. (Friday 12 September 2025; 16:36) this is a reply to message 111,126

Why the dislike? (111,126) by TJ from Norway Thank God I Found You and Don't Forget About Us are such a snore-fest. They don't belong with the rest of the number ones. There are so many songs in Mariah's catalogue that should have reach the top spot, but didn't. These two are not the ones. (Friday 12 September 2025; 12:09)

Here For It All streaming party countdown (111,129) by Edward from USA "With the lead single 'Emotions' ('You're So Cold' was initially considered) she became the first and only artist ever to send her first five singles to #1 on the Hot 100. Legend behavior and it was only album #2." That information is inaccurate since Whitney Houston set a record by sending seven consecutive singles to #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 between 1985 and 1988. She broke the previous record held by The Beatles (six consecutive #1's). "Saving All My Love for You" (1985) "How Will I Know" (1986) "Greatest Love of All" (1986) "I Wanna Dance with Somebody" (1987) "Didn't We Almost Have It All" (1987) "So Emotional" (1987) "Where Do Broken Hearts Go" (1988) Mariah was getting close, she had five straight #1's before "Can't Let Go" broke the streak. If Sony hadn't pulled the single from shelves, she could have tied "The Beatles" of six consecutive #1's. But since her later Emotions singles didn't top the chart, she wouldn't have surpassed Whitney. (Friday 12 September 2025; 16:19) this is a reply to message 111,128

Here For It All streaming party countdown (111,128) by 4real4real from UK Day 2 - Emotions (1991) + MTV Unplugged EP + Emotions EP + Make It Happen EP + Can You Hear Me (The Rarities) Today we're streaming Emotions - aka Mariah's "I'm not a one-album wonder" moment. For those of you joining us we will delve deeper in to R&B and gospel territory with splashes of dance and even a jazzy moment (where are our "The Wind" fans at?). Some say "And You Don't Remember" is her best ballad, others "Can't Let Go". They are both included on this spectacular sophomore effort. With the lead single "Emotions" ("You're So Cold" was initially considered) she became the first and only artist ever to send her first five singles to #1 on the Hot 100. Legend behavior and it was only album #2. She proved the naysayers wrong with the MTV Unplugged EP - including the ultimate version of "Someday" and the Hot 100 #1 "I'll Be There" cover with Trey Lorenz. Also check out "Can You Hear Me" from The Rarities, which was written during this era. How was this not even a B-Side, at least? Today's plan: blast the Emotions album with us, followed by the EPs and "Can You Hear Me", then go full living-room concert with MTV Unplugged. Let's show some love to this underrated era. I don't have any social media accounts so feel free to spread this far and wide. (Friday 12 September 2025; 15:30)

Why the dislike? (111,119) by Edward from USA It's not that I dislike "Thank God I Found You", I just don't really care for it. To me, it feels generic and overcrowded, almost as if Mariah was unsuccessfully trying to recreate the magic of "One Sweet Day". While I don't think it truly deserved the #1 spot, I can admit it's still a decent song. And no, I'd never compare it to Crapfinity, that one is in a league of hideous all on its own. Mariah had a golden chance to redeem that track with the "Why You Mad Remix", ft big names of the moment like Justin Bieber, French Montana, and T.I., yet somehow the result was even worse. On the flip side, the "Thank God I Found You (Make It Last Remix)" is fantastic, and I believe it played a huge role in pushing the original to the top of the charts. (Friday 12 September 2025; 01:56) this is a reply to message 111,116

Why the dislike? (111,116) by Tevin from USA But why, what's the reasoning behind your feelings of why it's mediocre? I'm asking out of curiosity, not hate. (Thursday 11 September 2025; 21:51)

MC + Busta Rhymes VMA After Party footage (111,101) by Edward from USA Relax, don't be a prude. Mariah and Busta go way back, they are friends, and friends say silly things, especially when they're happy and drunk, lol. Busta has the utmost respect for Mariah. I would like to hump on Mariah's leg myself, go figure. It's called the Mariah effect. Those two are friends, nobody took that seriously. Mariah was goofing around too. They were happy and celebrating getting their Moon Man. (Thursday 11 September 2025; 01:53) this is a reply to message 111,094

MC + Busta Rhymes VMA After Party footage (111,094) by BFF from United States I don't know if anyone watched any of the videos floating around. First of all, Busta *twice* said he wanted to hump Mariah's leg. He would not be anywhere near the top of my list of men for Mariah to hook up with. Secondly, she seemed really out of it when they started singing along to "I Know What You Want". I don't know if it was just alcohol consumption, but she was very glassy-eyed in that footage. Yet another reason why I'm worried about her and worried that she's working too hard. (Wednesday 10 September 2025; 21:10)

So... thoughts on the VMA performance? (111,083) by Edward from USA Those pre-recorded vocals sounded good and clean. I personally feel goog I don't have to worry much when she's lipping. It's been exhausting all these years. (Wednesday 10 September 2025; 03:38) this is a reply to message 111,072

So... thoughts on the VMA performance? (111,072) by jaker20 from US It seems like new pre-recorded vocals, and I like that. At least she's putting some new effort on new vocals. But she's still got a lot to improve on her lipping. Celine is a great lipper, for many years people thought she's always singing live. The same with Beyonce, but it's easier for her to lip because she's dancing a lot. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 18:55)

Help me there’s stairs (111,065) by Edward from USA Jamie, what I don't get is why Mariah puts herself in those sky-high heels when she knows people will drag her for not moving. She could easily wear something more comfortable. Did you see the height of those heels? I don't see the point of wearing heels if you can't gracefully rock them. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 17:11) this is a reply to message 111,059

Help me there’s stairs (111,059) by Jamie from UK Yeah it's become a bit of a joke on social media about her not moving. People shouldn't really joke about it if they don't know what's. I guess being honest would shut them down but like you said she isn't going to do that. 26th can't come quick enough. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 13:23)

KATSEYE (111,064) by Edward from USA It doesn't surprise me that they didn't know. A lot of Gen Z's can barely keep track of anything with the overload of information constantly coming at them. Here in New York, schools actually banned cellphones during class hours, and even the students admitted they were better off without them. Back when things were simpler, kids were more connected and social, now it feels like they're living in a cloud. These days, it's the phones and tablets raising them, not real interactions. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 17:05) this is a reply to message 111,060

KATSEYE (111,060) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter KATSEYE was asked at the VMAs red carpet about their favorite Mariah song and none of them could name 1 song. Just 1 girl was like (My All) and the rest were like so confused and one girl asked the girl who named the song to give her a title as well. Now I don't know this group well, but apparently they're popular but for them not to know a single song by the legend that is Mariah Carey is insane. Like I don't expect them to know her full catalogue but if nothing else at least say AIWFCIY. And there are so many viral Mariah songs on TikTok. Also you're on a red carpet where she's winning a major award, you should have been more prepared to answer that question. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 15:22)

Help me there’s stairs (111,063) by Edward from USA Mariah is stiff because she exercises with her high heels on. In Mariah's case, it's call stiff-stiletto syndrome. It's obvious. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 16:53) this is a reply to message 111,061

Help me there’s stairs (111,061) by Lara from Middle East Is it the medications? Or sequelae from her fall when she dislocated her shoulder? Sometimes I feel it's Mariah not Céline who has the stiff syndrome. Unfortunately, the young generation will probably tell her she's too old or just being a diva, while there's a real issue here. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 15:50)

So... thoughts on the VMA performance? (111,049) by Edward from USA I never saw the day I would say this, but at this point I prefer some good lipping over some vocal fiasco. At least she seems more relaxed when lipping. I think she did a good job. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 02:46) this is a reply to message 111,046

So... thoughts on the VMA performance? (111,046) by Bobby A from United States I Shazamed every song in the mix and the same results came back not so surprising. There was such a mix of prerecorded and live vocals that Shazam came back with these results. Big Energy/Obsessed/Honey/Herartbreaker - prerecorded from the Global Citzens Concert Fantasy ft. Ol' Dirty Bastard - mixed vocal recording with live vocals We Belong Together - prerecorded, live vocals and the Late Night Valentine Mix - (in my opinion) We still love MC. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 01:52)

VMAs (111,048) by Edward from USA Bobby A, let's be positive but realistic. "Caution" sold 51k on its first week. I would say 50-100k. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 02:41) this is a reply to message 111,044

VMAs (111,044) by Bobby A from United States MC is going to score big with HFIA. I just feel it. Once people hear Jesus I Do and Mi, the album will have a huge debut on the Billboard 200. Maybe 150K - 200K is more like it. I am going to leave my sales prediction numbers alone now. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 01:40)

VMAs: somewhere in a dark room (111,041) by Edward from USA Mariah was Christina's idol since she was a little girl. The problem with Christina, in my humble opinion, is that she went into her own "Metamorphosis" too soon. By her second album, she had gone from "girl next door" to "girl butt wild". Had she not made that comment about Mariah, they would've probably been in good terms. But her biggest mistake ever was acting the way she did towards the Queen of Soul. (Tuesday 9 September 2025; 00:11) this is a reply to message 111,022

VMAs: somewhere in a dark room (111,022) by John from USA Sits Christina watching Mariah and Ariana on TV giving love to one another. Ariana honoring and being reverential, and Mariah giving back the support and acknowledgement. Christina must be saying to herself: Why can't it be me? (Monday 8 September 2025; 14:13)

VMAs (111,035) by Edward from USA I actually like how everything played out. The rest of the year belongs to Mariah. These are exciting times. (Monday 8 September 2025; 20:25) this is a reply to message 111,018

VMAs (111,018) by Bobby A from United States It was a great performance and speech that MC gave last night. I loved it. (Monday 8 September 2025; 12:51)

We Belong Together (111,029) by Edward from USA That snippet of "We Belong Together" floating around on the Internet sounds great to me, but it also looks a little bit suspicious. Any comments? (Monday 8 September 2025; 17:47)

The Moon Man (111,026) by Edward from USA I loved Mariah's camaraderie with Ariana. I'm so glad Mariah changed her attitude towards Ari about three years ago or so. Ariana referring to Mariah as "mother", given the significance of that, it's simply epic and the greatest show of respect. I'm very proud of both of them. I can't effing wait for "HFIA". (Monday 8 September 2025; 15:49)

Daydream (111,025) by Edward from USA That's been settled almost from the inception of MCArchives. (Monday 8 September 2025; 15:36) this is a reply to message 111,023

Daydream (111,023) by Stacey from USA Daydream is perfection. You're saying it's not. I'm arguing it is indeed perfect. Carey on. I know I will. (Monday 8 September 2025; 14:40)

Best R&B (111,006) by Edward from USA They usually do that on most award shows. If they didn't, these shows would be way longer than usual. (Monday 8 September 2025; 04:36) this is a reply to message 111,001

Best R&B (111,001) by Dove from United States They gave a bunch of awards during the pre-show. I kept wondering what was going to be left for the actual show. I guess we'll see. Also, I meant to type "I'm so happy for us" in my last post. (Monday 8 September 2025; 01:56)

It's coming (110,991) by Edward from USA I can't wait for "Here For It All" to finally drop. Looking forward to reading the reactions here. (Sunday 7 September 2025; 16:05)

Kai Cenat's stream (110,981) by Edward from USA That's why I like the interview, she was uncomfortable on that chair, sitting so low, her inner diva would've pulled a RuPaul and sasheyed away, but instead, she adapted and look real. The diva was gone, the woman, the artist was there. That's the Mariah I miss. (Sunday 7 September 2025; 02:05) this is a reply to message 110,975

Kai Cenat's stream (110,975) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Another thing I remembered of her being very humble in this interview is that when she came in she pulled her own chair, didn't make a fuss about lighting and angles and just was very chill. No makeup artist or hairstylist running in and out fixing her hair. (Saturday 6 September 2025; 17:17)

Kai Cenat's stream (110,967) by Edward from USA I agree. Mariah has been looking disengaged on many of her regular interviews, but she had kind of a motherly attitude with Kai and his friends. (Saturday 6 September 2025; 03:53) this is a reply to message 110,962

Kai Cenat's stream (110,962) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter I think the fact that it was so chaotic made Mariah be more engaged haha. Because she had no idea what's coming next and so she was paying attention. In normal sit downs she gets bored. Also I'm not familiar with the streaming world but I think they keep looking at the screen because they are constantly getting alerts, donations, prompts, questions in the chat etc so they're managing the stream and keeping their audience engaged in real time also ensuring the technical side of things are running smooth. So that's why it's so chaotic. I think he was very respectful of Mariah and so were the other guys in the back. She looked like she felt appreciated. Of course they don't know her catalogue as well as we do so they'd appear a little out of touch. But yes I think she's teaming up with these streamers to widen her younger audience which is smart. This paid off more than Mr Beast. (Friday 5 September 2025; 21:35)

Daydream (110,961) by Edward from USA I can understand why "One Night" didn't make the final cut. While it definitely possesses the "Daydream" voice and delivery, its subject doesn't go well with the theme of the album. (Friday 5 September 2025; 20:28) this is a reply to message 110,955

Daydream (110,955) by Bill from the UK "Open Arms" is indeed stunning and breath taking in its simplicity and understated beauty. I love the way she made it sound so "Mariah", in that it went from this 80s rock power ballad anthem to a gorgeous moving restrained ballad. "Slipping Away" is an amazing song, I don't think any will disagree, but I always loved its underground status it had. I agree I'm not sure it would have fitted in with the other tracks on Daydream. As for "One Night", a hard no and a hard pass from me. I was a bit shocked that was a Daydream outtake as it seemed more "E=MC2" to me. Adding it to the album would have detracted from its sophistication in my view. (Friday 5 September 2025; 10:06)

Kai Cenat's stream (110,954) by Edward from USA Dear Bill, as I told Randy, I guess we're getting old. The beauty of the interview was in its messiness. Kai wasn't being disrespectful, he was being himself, messy, but authentic. I was like: can you stop with what's on the screen and focus on Ms. Carey? They were just being typical gen z's. He has 1.3M subscribers more than Mariah. The mission was accomplished. (Friday 5 September 2025; 04:36) this is a reply to message 110,949

Kai Cenat's stream (110,949) by Bill from the UK I couldn't watch it because it was so infuriatingly bad. Mariah looked great and I'm sure she represented herself well, but I'm guess I'm out of touch as the host was incoherent and an absolute unprofessional mess as was the others that materialised. I gave up after the Heartbreaker acapella when not one of them knew the word "incessantly". An absolute car crash and way below the standard Mariah should be at. (Friday 5 September 2025; 00:23)

Daydream (110,953) by Edward from USA "Open Arms" is one of Mariah's finest covers. The track that really deserved a spot on "Daydream" is "One Night". While "Slipping Away" is a great song, I don't think it would've blended well sonically with the rest of the album. Suggesting that "Slipping Away" should've replaced "Open Arms" is sacrilegious and a clear violation of the sacred "Daydream" code. Messing with the integrity of a Mariah's masterpiece is an automatic ban on this board. This time is just a slight reprimand, but don't let it happen again. (Friday 5 September 2025; 04:22) this is a reply to message 110,944

Daydream (110,944) by Giovanni from USA Is definitely one of her best and what would have made it better is if "Slipping away" had made the album. I would have swapped out "Open arms" for "Slipping away" and I know Tommy was the reason why it didn't make the album. I love Journey but "Open arms" is the one song I don't care for. I also believe Daydream Mariah would have covered "At your best (you are love)" perfectly. "Fantasy" is one of her biggest hits but one I never play, I prefer playing "One sweet day" and "Always be my baby". I prefer Butterfly Mariah because of her raspy tone, also the "Butterfly" album cover is her best album cover in my opinion. I also loved what would have been "The art of letting go" album cover but Mariah changed it which was disappointing because it's a very nice album cover. I'm happy with the "Here for it all" album cover. She looks happy and like the legend she is. Mariah has such a nice smile. (Thursday 4 September 2025; 22:27)

When I saw you (110,941) by Edward from USA When I Saw You has always been one of my favorites from "Daydream". It's incredible that Mariah, at such a young age, crafted lyrics with so much depth, beauty and emotional resonance. To me, she never quite captured that same poetic magic again after "Charmbracelet", with the exception of "Randy's Theme". The songs she wrote later on were still heartfelt, but their structures felt a bit simpler and less poetic by comparison. (Thursday 4 September 2025; 20:29) this is a reply to message 110,939

When I saw you (110,939) by Bobby A from United States There is a lot of imagery in When I Saw. WISY is one of my favorite MC ballads. (Thursday 4 September 2025; 17:24)

When I saw you (110,938) by Edward from USA Her voice on Daydream is just like butter. Smooth, nuanced, powerful but never too showy. Daydream is pure perfection. In my humble opinion, "Butterfly" is her magnum opus though. That album could've been titled "Metamorphosis". When I saw Mariah on "Honey", so sexy and beutiful, for a moment I questioned my sexuality. (Thursday 4 September 2025; 17:01) this is a reply to message 110,936

When I saw you (110,936) by TJ from Norway I've been revisiting Daydream lately, and just have to say her voice is so perfect on that track. Worth a listen. (Thursday 4 September 2025; 15:21)

MORE MESSAGES