Messageboard

Publicity stunt (36,426) by Licia from USA I agree with Will. Nicki is a fool if she is willing to take all this backlash for ratings. She's already disliked. Why would she make it worse for herself? I'm going to be real upset if I find out that this is a stunt though. Lol. I also agree about the songwriting and producing. Of course we know all that she is capable of, but for whatever reason it's important for her to make sure the world knows what she is capable of. I agree that she should not have to prove herself anymore, but she has always had to go that extra mile to prove herself, even when she was at her very best. (Friday 5 October 2012; 15:27)

Edward/publicity stunt? No (36,425) by Will from England I think she only says it because she wants to emphasize the point that she does not consider herself a singer first, as she has always done. She categorizes her song writing and producer above that. Singing is what she's known for, but she wants to highlight that she's more than just a singer, especially with a show like American Idol, showing that she's bringing more things to the table rather than just saying "I stand there and sing Hero." Especially with Nicki on the table, who does write and produce her own stuff, Mariah doesn't want to feel as if Nicki is better than she is (which of course, we all know isn't true) and has more to bring to the show. To me, it's a warped version of "anything you can do, I've been doing for longer and can do it better". And this isn't a publicity stunt. Why? Let me explain. Why would anyone, in any job, agree to publicly humiliate and degrade themselves, just to get better ratings for a show? No one, no matter how much you're getting paid. It makes no sense at all for this to be a stunt. Remember in 2010 when Bruno dropped down butt naked onto Eminem at some award show? That's a stunt. This isn't. Nicki still has an marketing image to keep for her to remain viable in the industry and something like this (as it has done) has destroyed the barbie doll image and shown her for who she is behind the cameras: a disrespecting brat. If this was a stunt, then Nicki was an idiot to agree to it and deserves all the backlash she gets. (Friday 5 October 2012; 14:03)

Publicity stunt (36,424) by Nattalie from USA Even though I don't believe this is real, I have to admit that this is great hilarious entertainment. I love it. Just like what Bob said in his comment, lets just sit back and enjoy the show. Mariah was here to entertain us in any form or fashion. She can still do this and keep her dignity. Like someone said, it reminds you of them reality TV shows. Even though this is entertainment, sadly it's only benefiting Mariah. Nicki is recieving no love lol. If she is, it's like 1/8 out of every 100th comment. Ha! (Friday 5 October 2012; 7:49)

Whoa, Mariah/Nicki Garbaj fued (36,422) by CDC from CA This has escalated to new heights. Many are wondering what instigated the blow out, and I've come up with a theory. I've read that the fight began over the disagreement over a contestant, specifically whether he or she would fit into what is "popular on the charts". Mariah says it won't make it, Nicki disagrees, then Mariah retaliates by referencing her achievement as being the artist with most number one hits in the country (hence, "running down her resume every five minutes"). Perhaps she said that Nicki, having never seen the top of the Billboard Hot 100, was "inadequate" to make comments about music charts. Thus was ignited the firestorm that is Nicki Minaj's mouth. Again, all this a theory. We all share a great admiration for Mariah, but you have to admit that Mariah's ego is through the roof, as it should be. She has career statistics that would make even Peyton Manning and Tom Brady genuflect in her presence. Mariah is by a wide margin one of the most famous, celebrated and powerful artists in pop music; but above all that, she is a master media manipulator. I can see her brilliant agenda. Evidence proves she never wanted another female (let alone one who is more flamboyant) on the panel, and the way she's conducting herself throughout this episode has the world on her side. Aside from the large gathering of celebrity support for Mariah on twitter, she had Barbara Walters talk down about Nicki Minaj as if she were OJ Simpson. Can it get any worse for Nicki? We'll see. Mariah was once married to the CEO and chairman of one of the biggest record labels in the world, so undoubtedly she's pocketed some cunning tricks through the years. She wants Nicki out of Idol, and after that twitter rant, she probably wants her out of the industry. I don't expect anyone to have even a flash of a memory of Nicki Minaj this time next year. Bubbling under the surface of butterflies and rainbows is a woman as cold, cunning and ruthless as an Elizabethan courtier. This makes me like her a lot more. Well played, Mariah. (Friday 5 October 2012; 4:46)

Mariah's hanging out with JD too much (36,421) by Edward from USA I'll always have Mariah's back, but it bothers me the fact that when you see her these days, she has to sound like JD all over people's records, regurgitating the same "I'm a song writer, I'm a producer, I'm a singer" statements. We know Mariah's a song writer, producer, vocalist, a true artist. Why does she have to say it every time she has the chance, specifically when talking about anything related to American Idol? She doesn't have anything to prove, her legacy is there. She sounds desperate every time she does that, it actually bothers me. Mariah's demeanor on the show and on the last few interviews has come across somewhat pretentious, pedantic. I think that Mariah had a beautiful demeanor when she was in her hey days. Now the diva attitude truly gets on my nerves. (Friday 5 October 2012; 2:02)

??? (36,420) by Stephen from London, United Kingdom Who's this Nicki Minaj everyone is speaking of? (shade intentional lol) (Thursday 4 October 2012; 22:44)

Another thing (36,419) by Lee from USA So Nicki is crying about Mimi's "lying" about death threats. Why would she lie to anyone? First, Nicki has a track record of disrespect and tirades. If you all don't believe me, ask Mo'Nique (and a whole lot of DJs and other rappers) and watch that "My Time Is Now" documentary. Then, she goes on Twitter ranting and raving about it. RIP Nicki Minaj's career 2009-2013. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 22:09)

The Minaj situation (36,418) by Anthony Carey from U.K Well keeping this short and sweet, I agree with a earlier post regarding people seem to all be backing Mariah, the public have come out in support which is actually really nice to see. With regards to the other silly looser Minaj, I just think she is a jumped up nobody. Yes, she is popular at the moment, but erm reality check, she aint no legacy in the making, is she? Idol need to just get rid of the trash and move on. Petition lambs perhaps? LYM (Thursday 4 October 2012; 22:00)

Re: JBfly (36,417) by nikki from usa Actually, I do remember Bedrock - that was a big one in '09. But, Nicki wasn't even mentioned on the track because she had a 10 second cameo - it just says ft. lloyd. Kinda like Ashanti was backup for Ja Rule with "Always on time" and she did eventually become big for awhile, but then there are people like Olivia from 50cents Candy Shop and has anyone heard from her since? That's why I didn't count that - it was too small and there was no name mention on the track. On Mariah's it was more of a duet and MC's fanbase reaches a larger demographic. Nicki got lots of face time, name mention, and a few months later Nicki's first song came out. Boards were ablaze with, "hey, that's the girl from the Mariah video" - it was a good stepping stone. According to the TMZ transcript, Nicki was bent outta shape because Mariah keeps talking about her resume. Which is why I think this is staged because if you've only been out a couple years, why would you be dogging a legend for bringing up her experience? I can't imagine Christina screaming at Aretha Franklin. And over the possible talent of a contestant? I think this is staged, it's just too stupid. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 19:30)

Feud transcript error (36,416) by Alexis from USA I regret to admit I was excited to hear that Mariah called someone the "b word" because she is always so composed and it was just never see that side. But, listening to the audio, that's not what she said. I hear "I can't see my kids because you decided to have a little baby fit." It's "baby fit" not "crazy b*tch". Her composure ruled again. Good for her. Bad for my interest in drama. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 17:10)

Re: Nikki (36,415) by JBfly from USA I just wanted to comment on your post. I agree with some of what you said. Even I couldn't understand what Nicki was saying, even if I play and watch it 100x. But I have to correct you on one thing though. Mariah wasn't the one who introduced Nicki to the mass. She was featured on a song called "Bedrock" by Young Money along with Lil' Wayne which reached no. 2 on Hot 100 way before OFMF was filmed. Though Nicki looked crazy on the video, there has to be some sort of reason for it. We only got to see her bust out curse words after curse words and didn't see the beginning of it. Maybe Mariah said something smart or maybe not, we will never know this. Also whether this was staged or not, it sure got some attention from the media. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 17:06)

The feud is good for Mariah? (36,414) by Will from England I think this could have a positive spin on it from Mariah's point of view. Reading some of the articles (many of them), it would seem that the general public is on Mariah's side. People who are not fans of her type of music are speaking out and supporting Mariah. Because, for once, there is an actual video of the incident in question, and not something generated by the rumor mills, which could easily be fabricated and twisted to make Mariah look bad. In this case, we have a clear idea of what is going on behind the cameras. True, it isn't the whole picture, but none the less, it's an idea. People are, once again, being reminded of what Mariah stands for as an artist, along with her talent and longevity, compared to Nicki. Whatever you say about Mariah being on Idol, in the long run, especially with an album on the way, this could play to her advantage in a massive way. She's getting the recognition she deserves. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 9:06)

Desiree (36,413) by Licia from USA If Mariah said something out of line, then she was wrong and I do believe she said something, but Nicki handled the situation badly. She made herself look really bad with all the cursing and yelling. She could have defended herself like an adult, but instead she threw a tantrum and she made herself look like a fool. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 9:03)

Why? (36,412) by nikki from usa I don't get this. I agree with Natalie, I think this is a publicity stunt. Clearly that video person wasn't supposed to be there because the audio is crappier than the footage. Where in the world did TMZ get a transcript? You certainly couldn't tell all that from the audio, it's guessing at best. TMZ has been trying to make catfights since before they ever met up for panel. If any part of the transcript is true, then Nicki flew off the handle, because MC keeps bringing up her "resume". Well, that's a fact, Mariah has an impressive resume, one that Nicki used to look up to. Not to mention MC was the first to introduce Nicki to the world with her music video before NM ever debuted. If MC has to bring up her "resume", one can only assume that Nicki isn't giving MC respect for her opinions. If this wasn't staged, then that was a pretty big tantrum for someone who's only been out 3 years. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 5:51)

Mariah and Minaj (36,411) by Anonymous from I believe this whole sorted afffair is nothing more than a publicity stunt designed to stir interest in a show that's been waning in popularity and in the the ratings game for years. Mariah's a business woman and she knows how to garner publicity. Everyone else involved in the show's been around long enough to know how to get the public's attention. Showbiz people love to wind us up and squeal with delight when we all go crazy over them. Mariah's not immune to this behavior either, so don't get on me. I love her, always have, always will, but let's face it. She been playing games with us Lambs for years and obviously we love it or we wouldn't be Lambs. It's part of being a fan of hers. So I say instead of getting on the various players in this soap opera, sit back and enjoy the entertainment they are providing us. What the heck, it's free. Enjoy the day everyone. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 4:58)

Geezy / Daydream (36,410) by Stacey from USA Oh man, I almost forgot. Daydream is my favorite MC album. So classic. So timeless. So amazing. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 4:25)

Get rid of Minaj (36,409) by Stacey from USA Honestly, they need to get rid of Minaj. Period. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 4:23)

On a positive note: (36,408) by Geezy from USA by way of NYC Today is the 17th anniversary of one of the greatest pop records ever: Daydream. As for that situation, it seems like this is what the media wanted and that's what they got. Personally, money can buy a lot of things, but it can't buy class. (Thursday 4 October 2012; 1:04)

Desiree (36,407) by RibbonB from USA Nicki is responsible for her own out of control behavior. And if any "normal" person snapped like that at work, they'd be fired. And we don't know what MC said or didn't say, all we really hear is what Nicki barked out. I do believe Idol and Fox are responsible for this "leak" and all for press. They need to clean this up. (Wednesday 3 October 2012; 22:02)

Death threats and violent language (36,406) by Fady from Lebanon I'm really disgusted by Nicki Minaj's behavior. Yes, she is doing well on the charts now, but she has no legitimacy to judge musical talent. So what if Mariah did talk about her "resume" (which is impressive and something to call upon)? Some people are saying Mariah "provoked" this unacceptable reaction. But this is all on Nicki Minaj and her choice of words and behavior. I am simply disgusted. And I hope Mariah remains above this pettiness. (Wednesday 3 October 2012; 20:17)

Nicki Minaj (36,405) by John from USA This girl is bat sh#%t crazy. She's been out for a few years, yet I can't name a single one of her songs. The way she was just cursing and screaming non-stop in the video was just insane. I wish I knew why AI hired her - she's not a singer, she's a rapper, and still very new to the scene. I don't know what Mariah said or did behind the scenes to provoke this, but I think she handled herself well in the video (she wasn't being a pig and cursing uncontrollaby like Minaj). Hey, if nothing else, it's at least some publicity for Mariah to keep her name alive. Lord knows her latest single (if you can call it that) is lost on the charts and ain't doing it lol. (Wednesday 3 October 2012; 18:45)

Mariah vs Nicki (36,404) by Desiree from USA I like Mariah Carey, but at the same time if you keep pushing someone's buttons, they bound to just push back and Mariah got cursed out. (Wednesday 3 October 2012; 17:56)

Nattalie (36,403) by RibbonB from USA I'm not sure what that was, but Nicki is unstable and she needs to go. Idol screwed up this whole process by hiring her in the first place. They have created an absurd mess and it will be interesting to see how they fix this mess. (Wednesday 3 October 2012; 16:52)

I see it this way (36,402) by Lee from USA How did a female rapper with little competition became a judge anyways? I am tired of being spoon-fed this bullmess about Minaj being the "queen of hip-hop" when she is the only female rapper in the game. All of her "rivals" are either going to jail, getting out of jail, or just irrelevant. (Wednesday 3 October 2012; 16:45)

Edward and Desiree (36,401) by John from USA I couldn't agree with you guys more. Mariah has completely lost her way; her projects and musical direction have been extremely unfocused since TEOM, and she is surrounded by awful management. I hope she has something up her sleeve. E=MC2 was great, but had no promotion after TMB. MOAIA came out too soon after, and was overshadowed by Precious (and it had no real viable singles after Obsessed), and the main version of Triumphant is just awful, probably her worst lead single ever. I agree Edward, Mariah is in no position to bring R&B back. She is no longer a "can do no wrong" artist and now has to deal with the "over 40" stigma (which is unfair, but true). This is why I wish she put more into E=MC2; she looked hot during that era, the album had endless singles, the public was on her side after TEOM, etc. Like Edward said, I know she'll always have her fans and is a legend, but after a certain amount of flops (waves at Janet Jackson), the public/radio just basically completely drop you. I feel like Mariah is so stubborn and hellbent on proving she is an R&B/Hip-hop artist and goes out of her way to deny her pop roots. I just wish she'd give the fans and general public what they want - catchy, upbeat songs with undeniable hooks and strong full-voice vocals, and no freaking rappers. But I'm not holding my breath. If she wants to give up chasing the Beatles and getting decent album sales (and lose even me, a dedicated lamb, as a fan), then that's fine. (Wednesday 3 October 2012; 16:33)

MORE MESSAGES